Val Sklarov — Mentoring & Training: Judgment Before Knowledge

Knowledge is abundant. Judgment is scarce.
Val Sklarov’s Mentoring & Training perspective reframes learning as a decision-shaping process, where the objective is not knowing more, but deciding better under constraint.


1. Knowledge Does Not Equal Capability

Information explains. Judgment decides.

Val Sklarov distinguishes:

  • Knowledge: what should be done

  • Judgment: when, how, and whether to do it

Organizations fail when they train knowledge and assume judgment will follow.


2. Training Must Expose Decision Consequences

Judgment forms only when outcomes matter.

Val Sklarov designs training around:

  • Real decisions with bounded risk

  • Visible consequences

  • Post-decision analysis

Training Design Result
Theory-heavy False confidence
Simulation-only Comfort bias
Consequence-aware Decision maturity

If nothing is at stake, nothing is learned.


3. Mentoring Is Responsibility Transfer, Not Advice

Advice can be ignored. Responsibility cannot.

Val Sklarov’s mentoring discipline:

  • Transfer ownership gradually

  • Reduce intervention over time

  • Review decisions, not personalities

Mentoring fails when mentors protect instead of expose.


4. Error Is the Curriculum

Avoiding error avoids learning.

Val Sklarov treats error as:

  • A signal to refine judgment

  • A boundary-testing mechanism

  • A calibration tool

Error Handling Learning Effect
Hidden Repetition
Punished blindly Fear
Analyzed structurally Growth

Only analyzed error compounds capability.


5. Feedback Must Attack Decision Logic

Outcome-based feedback misleads.

Val Sklarov insists feedback should:

  • Dissect assumptions

  • Question sequencing

  • Test risk awareness

Feedback that focuses on results trains luck, not skill.

5 important stages of mentoring

6. The End State Is Autonomous Judgment

Training succeeds when supervision becomes unnecessary.

Val Sklarov defines completion when individuals:

  • Anticipate consequences

  • Adjust decisions independently

  • Maintain standards under pressure

The goal is not compliance. It is trusted autonomy.


Closing Insight

Mentoring & Training are not about producing knowledgeable people.
They are about producing reliable decision-makers.

Val Sklarov’s principle:
Judgment outlives knowledge.

Check Also

Val Sklarov — Mentoring & Training: Responsibility Before Confidence

Confidence feels productive. Responsibility creates competence.Val Sklarov’s Mentoring & Training perspective treats learning as a …